Best Smudge-proof Mascara For Oily Skin: Top Option & Review 2020

10 Best Smudge Proof Mascara For Oily Skin 2023

Looking for a long lasting mascara? Here are the best smudge proof mascara for oily skin. Check it out!

The reason why you should take a look at these best smudge proof mascara oily skin is that one of the most annoying things about having oily skin is that your lids can be oily too. 

Usually, while a mascara helps to hold a curl, it fails to stay due to the excessive oils coming through your eyelids. This means it’s better for you to try something that’s more on the smudge-proof side to effectively prevent any mascara melt-off. 

How do you keep mascara from smudging under your eyes?

Mascara smudges are one of the biggest beauty blunders out there. Whether you’re on a first date, running late for a meeting, or just in front of the mirror, you don’t want your perfect mascara look to be ruined by panda eyes or raccoon marks. So, how do you keep mascara from smudging under your eyes?

You can start with always using good quality products. Make sure your mascara has a water-resistant formula, and always try to use a formula that is specifically made to keep your mascara from smudging. Investing in a good formula will help to keep your lashes looking luscious and not sagging with smudges.

You can also prevent mascara smudges by doing some pre-mascara prep. Before you apply your mascara, use a primer to help your mascara to stay put. Apply the primer to your eye lashes before putting on mascara, to form a base for the mascara to stick on. This can also help to keep moisture away from your upper eyelids, preventing your mascara from smudging.

When you’re applying your mascara, don’t be too heavy handed or apply too much. Too much mascara can weigh down your lashes, dragging them down and encouraging smudging. Start off with less and keep building up until you reach the desired look. Make sure you use an even and wiggling motion when applying your mascara to help spread the product and separate the lashes.

When you’re taking off your mascara, use a quality remover. You can find removers with either oil or water-based formulas to get the job done as easily as possible. A good remover will help to prevent smudging, because it can instantly remove excess product, meaning your mascara won’t have the chance to stick to your skin.

Finally, make sure to always blot excess moisture from the eyes. After removing your mascara, use a clean cloth to gently dab away any remaining moisture. This helps to stop mascara smearing and smudging, because the moisture won’t be able to move the mascara.

Top Smudge Proof Mascara For Oily skin

Let’s dive into these products to find out which one is the best mascara for oily lids!

Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Waterproof Mascara

Maybelline has forever been well-known for its fabulous mascaras: they are accessible, money-saving and undeniably effective. This particular one holds an irreplaceable position among its best-sellers. It adds volume to eyelashes, keeping them curled without feeling itchy and is impossible to rub off. 

This mascara is also formulated with vitamin E, which explains why it glides on so smoothly and doesn’t flake during application. Moreover, it is undefeatable when it comes to the price point. If you love Maybelline products, this one is a must-try!


  • Elongates eyelashes and keeps them curled
  • Waterproof and smudgeproof
  • Comfortable to wear
  • Not brittle or clumpy
  • Drugstore 


  • May be hard to remove

Tetyana naturals 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

This mascara does a great job of holding a curl as well as creating bold looks that last all day long. It is waterproof and flake-free, user-friendly. If you had experience with mascara smearing around your eyes, rest assured that it won’t happen again with this one. 

In addition, it gives more definition to eyelashes without clumping. It’s a great tool for creating glamorous eye looks. Overall, a top-rated product that’s worth the hype!


  • Waterproof and long-lasting
  • Doesn’t smudge through sweat
  • Holds a curl
  • Great for dramatic looks


  • Can get a bit clumpy when applied
  • Wet formula, doesn’t dry quickly

MOSTORY Black Lash Mascara

If you heard about their wonderful eyebrow product, you should positively check this one out! It makes your lashes appear longer and more discernible after only one coat, doesn’t smudge and is equipped with a great brush for easy application. 

This one has a minor downside which is its wet formula, so you are not recommended to apply in a tearing hurry, or it will be a disaster. Give it a few minutes to completely dry out and you’ll have flawless, long-lasting eyelashes ready for any unexpected events. 


  • Affordable
  • Makes eyelashes longer and fuller
  • Doesn’t flake or smudge throughout the day
  • Nice curved brush for smooth application
  • Heavy packaging


  • Takes a while to dry
  • May not lengthen short lashes


It’s time for you and your lashes to glow up with the Extra Bold Mascara from Laura Geller.

With plant-based waxes in the formula, this mascara can lift your mascara to the sky while maintaining its strength and flexibility. Your lashes will once again be reborn with a new look of densifying and healthy being. This mascara’s brush is the combination of traditional mascara bristles to help even out the product on your lashes, along with a sculpting tip to help curve your lashes most naturally without detecting any clumping or smearing. 

Due to the accessible design of this mascara, it is straightforward to handle the lashes at angles, including outer lashes, lower lashes, etc. Though this mascara formula contains water-resistant factors, the product can be removed easily without any harsh effort at the end of the day. How nice is it?

With all of its benefits for your lashes and your eyes, it is worth spending a fortune on this Laura Geller mascara for gorgeous eyes with stunning lashes performance.


  • Lift your lashes naturally
  • No smudging and smearing
  • Water-resistant
  • Easy to remove


  • None

Stila HUGE Extreme Lash Mascara

As the name refers, Stila has guaranteed to turn your straight dull lashes into extremely huge lashes. The brand has confirmed that this mascara produces the best result in thickening and lengthening lashes at the same time. Get ready for stunning voluminous and sky-rocket lashes with just a few swipes. 

If you want to pop out your eyes and your beautiful eye makeup then choosing the perfect mascara will finish the game. Stila’s mascara can define your eyes while separating those lashes and curl each one of them for a brighter and bolder overall appearance. 

Whether it is an everyday look or a night party, Stila mascara can rock them all and still yet comes off effortlessly for removal. This game-changing mascara is safe from any kind of water and should be put into your shopping cart right away. Don’t be put off by its price. You won’t be disappointed with what this mascara can bring to your eyes.

Grande Cosmetics Conditioning Peptide Mascara

This mascara’s brand may sound distant to you, but trust us, once you get your lashes under this mascara, you will never think of being distant to it anymore. 

Not only emphasizes your eyes through the volumizing lashes, but this mascara also nourishes your lashes thanks to the extract of peptides, panthenol, and natural waxes. Once you have this mascara removed, your lashes will be conditioned enough for a healthy look for the next use. 

Thanks to the not-totally-dense formula, you can build up as many mascara layers as you want without making your lashes feeling heavy. Also, the mascara does not result in any following imperfections, including smearing or smudging, make sure you have a perfect eye look all day. Not to mention the water-repellant factor that makes this Grand Cosmetics mascara a must for any girl’s makeup wardrobe. Spending a fortune on this and you will understand why money always goes with high-quality

Talika Lipocils Set

No one wants to be caught at the moment when her lashes have all fallen in the afternoon. Purchasing a high-end mascara requires the product itself to have the ability to keep our lashes lifted all the time. If you haven’t found a mascara that serves your wish, this is the time when you should prep your lashes with Lipocils. Lipocils is a gel that helps nourish your lashes’ condition along with lifting and strengthening lashes naturally. In case you suffer from short, dull lashes, this item is recommended solely for you. Within a few weeks of applying this set your mascara, your lashes will become more durable, denser, and shinier. 

Before applying any mascara, apply Lipocils first on your lashes’ root as the prime step. You can also use Lipocils every day for slow yet effective improvement on your lashes. 

Although the price seems to be quite stressful, it is a wise choice to invest in preparing the base before striking for any after effect. 

Talika Lipocils Set

How to make mascara stays longer

Step 1: Prepare your eyelids with eyeshadow primer

We are talking about best smudge-proof mascara for oily skin, why should we care about eyeshadow primer? For the most part, mascara is melted and smears a lot due to the excessive oil coming through your eyelids. That’s why it becomes more vital to put on primer, in order to not only enhance the pigment of your eyeshadow but also assure that it doesn’t let any oil spread out.

best smudge proof mascara oily skin

Step 2: Apply eyelash primer

It’s important to take proper care of your natural eyelashes, especially when you have oily skin. Apart from its ability to grab your mascara, eyelash primer also protects your lashes from any damage from the removing process. This is explained by the fact that waterproof mascaras are usually difficult to remove, so we tend to aggressively pull and tub our lashes, which can lead to their fall off.

best smudge proof mascara oily skin

Step 3: Choose an excellent waterproof product

Waterproof mascaras are made for extremely greasy eyelids. They make our lashes look like we have extensions, compliment our look and keep it flawless through any occasions. If normal mascaras don’t work for you, waterproof would be your stable. 

best smudge proof mascara oily skin

Fact: Saline solution helps to extend mascara longevity

Besides choosing the best smudge-proof mascara for oily skin, Saline solution is in fact a substance made by mixing salt and water. Normally it is used to treat open wounds and dehydration or remove contact lenses.

best smudge proof mascara oily skin

The common problem of any waterproof or smudge-proof mascara is that they dry too quickly (about 4 months since opened). One of the easiest and most effective ways to tackle this is to use saline solution: squeeze roughly 3 drops into the tub, mix them a little bit and your mascara will be resuscitated in the wink of an eye. 

If the saline solution is unavailable, try eye drops and they will work just as well.

Which mascara is best for oily skin?

Secret Xpress 4D Silk Fiber EyeLash Mascara is one of the most recommended smudge-proof mascaras for oily skin. This hypoallergenic mascara will add length and volume to your lashes, making them look fuller. The long-lasting formula is perfect if you need a waterproof option because it doesn’t smudge or flake even when applied on oily skin.

What is a good smudge proof mascara?

A good smudge-proof mascara never fails in keeping your lashes lifted and looking great, no matter how hot the weather is. Maybelline Full ‘N Soft Waterproof Mascara ranks as the best-selling waterproof mascara. It passed several smudging Lab tests, retains curls well and comes at a budget-friendly price.

Why does my mascara keep smudging under my eyes?

If you tend to get your mascara smudged, avoid using cream products on that area. Cream eyeshadows, eyeliners and eye creams not only create an oily slippery surface due to which your mascara gets smudged under your eyes.

Is waterproof mascara good for oily eyelids?

There are different types of mascara but the best choice for oily skin is a waterproof mascara. They’re specifically made to resist moisture, which means that they’ll last even with oily skin and eyes! Tubing mascaras also work well if your eye lids are oily.

Final Thoughts

These amazing products are certified smudge-proof and proven to work with oily skin or through sweaty activities. The market already bombards you with so many choices, so we hope this list tide you over with that. 

Our last advice: remember to buy an effective, gentle makeup remover in order to minimize damage to your lashes. You don’t need to prioritize oil-based over micellar water, just do some research first and you’ll figure out which is the best mascara for oily skin.

Let us know what you think about our review about best smudge proof mascara oily skin in the comments below!

Read also:




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *